Still no contract a year after union vote, but Rio counterparts undaunted
By Liz
Benston
Tue, Jun
24, 2008
(2 a.m.)
Over the
past
several
months,
newly
organized
dealers
at Wynn
Las
Vegas
and
Caesars
Palace
have
reached
tentative
agreements
with
their
employers
over
contract
terms
spelling
out job
procedures,
benefits
and
other
basic
aspects
of the
job.
Breaks?
Check.
Stocked
vending
machines?
Check.
Vacation
time?
Check.
But
resolving
more
sensitive
issues
having
to do
with
grievances
and
tip-sharing
is
testing
the
ability
of the
Transport
Workers
Union to
flex its
muscle
at a
time
when
it’s
trying
to
organize
still
more
dealers,
this
time at
the Rio.
More
than a
year
after
dealers
at Wynn
Las
Vegas
voted
nearly
3-1 for
union
representation,
there’s
no sign
of a
contract.
Wynn
became
the
first
property
to vote
in the
union
after
Steve
Wynn
implemented
a
controversial
plan for
dealers
to share
part of
their
tips
with
supervisors.
Dealers
at
Caesars
voted
for
union
representation
in
December,
and Rio
dealers
will
vote
July 12.
Joseph
Carbon,
director
of
Transport
Workers
Union
Local
721,
said
it’s not
unusual
for
first
contracts
to take
at least
a year.
“I know
that
we’re
the new
kids on
the
block in
gaming,
but this
is
expected,”
even
when
workers
are
already
unionized
elsewhere,
Carbon
said.
“We’re
here to
stay.”
Neither
casino
management
nor the
union
will
reveal
particulars
of their
negotiations.
“We
continue
to meet
with the
TWU
regularly
and
negotiate
in good
faith,”
Wynn
spokeswoman
Jennifer
Dunne
said.
Gary
Thompson,
spokesman
for
Caesars
and Rio
owner
Harrah’s
Entertainment,
added:
“We
continue
to
negotiate
in good
faith,
but
won’t
discuss
details
of the
talks.”
Any
frustration
among
dealers
at Wynn
or
Caesars
Palace
pales in
comparison
with
what is
playing
out in
Atlantic
City,
where
dealers
are
represented
by the
United
Auto
Workers.
Labor
groups
are
criticizing
Tropicana
and
Caesars
in
Atlantic
City for
dragging
their
feet in
contract
talks,
and
negotiations
at two
other
casinos
haven’t
even
begun
because
management
is
contesting
the
election
results.
Gaming
insiders
say it’s
unlikely
that
Wynn
will
reverse
his tip
policy —
the
central
concern
of Wynn
dealers.
And
greater
job
security,
a top
concern
at
Caesars
and the
Rio,
won’t be
an easy
sell for
any of
the
casinos,
which
covet
the
ability
to fire
employees
at will
for
infractions
of
varying
severity.
It’s
never
been
easy,
winning
a
contract
for
organized
dealers
in this
town.
About
eight
years
ago,
dealers
at
several
Strip
casinos
voted
for
representation
by the
Transport
Workers
Union —
only to
cut bait
with the
union
two
years
later
because
no
contracts
had been
signed.
Wynn
dealers
promise
to stick
with a
union
this
time
because
their
earnings
are at
stake
with the
tip-sharing
policy.
Rio
dealer
Debbie
Bradley
is
hoping
to
organize
under
the
Transport
Workers
Union
even if
it
hasn’t
struck a
contract
at Wynn
and
Caesars
Palace.
“They
say they
have no
plans to
take our
tokes,
but
companies
are
always
making
plans,”
Bradley
said of
Rio
management.
“We need
to
protect
what we
have
now.”
Executives
at MGM
Mirage
have
forwarded
written
promises
to
dealers
not to
have
them
share
their
tips
with
floor
managers,
and
Bellagio
dealers
recently
got a
raise —
a rarity
for
workers
whose
base
wages
are
little
more
than the
federal
minimum.
And
Thompson
said his
company
has
“never
contemplated”
a change
to its
tip
policy.
Still,
some
dealers
at
Caesars
and Rio
say they
have
more
reason
to
worry:
the
possibility
of
dramatic
staff
cuts now
that
Harrah’s
is
privately
held,
and in
the
future,
should
the
company
change
hands
again.
In
recent
months,
MGM
Mirage
has laid
off more
workers
in Las
Vegas
than has
Harrah’s,
according
to the
companies’
estimates.
Besides
concern
over tip
sharing,
Rio
workers
say they
worry
about
changes
in their
health
care and
retirement
plans.
Roulette
dealer
David
Fehrman
said he
resents
what he
calls
“micromanaging”
bosses
who are
requiring
dealers
to use
players’
names in
conversation,
to tout
restaurants
and
other
hotel
attractions
to
players
and to
“high-five”
their
wins.
“There’s
a lot of
pressure
when
you’re
dealing
high-stakes
games.
And now
I’ve got
to worry
that
I’ll get
written
up for
not
high-fiving
a player
while
I’m
trying
to pay
off
players
and
people
are
grabbing
chips
off the
table,”
said
Fehrman,
who
started
at the
Rio when
it
opened
in 1990.
Thompson’s
response:
“No one
enjoys
sitting
at a
table
with a
grouchy
dealer,
and
dealers
who
smile
and
otherwise
engage
with
their
customers
generally
earn
higher
tips.”
Fehrman
said his
top
priority
is
keeping
his job.
“Even
after 18
years of
commendable
service
in the
business
I go to
work
worried
every
day,”
Fehrman
said. “I
want
this to
be my
last
job. But
the only
way I
can do
that is
with a
union.”
[up]
